“Ex-post, Ex-ante” + When rates will fall

U.S. Home Prices will Fall

Welcome to our newly revamped weekly product, where we do a quick summary of salient news over the past week and what to expect the following week and beyond. It took a while to think of a catchy name for our weekly and we hope you like it. We also plan to include our house view of the major macro events and, of course, how it all relates to the global real estate markets, in particular the US.

Contents:

  • Ex-post; Ex-ante
  • Will rates decline? Yes, starting in March!
  • Why US home prices will not collapse
  • Buyer’s Guide to California
  • Loans of the week! 

Ex-post

Last week saw major headlines with UK printing a 10% inflation number and Europe continuing to see hefty price increases in energy costs, with Germany at €700 ($696) a megawatt-hour, up from under €50 in January. 

In the US, mortgage applications dipped slightly for the week ending August 12, 2022, down 2.3% week on week. Things are generally slower in all areas of the economy in August, and this is no different. 

30-year fixed rate 5.45% mortgages are down 50 bps from June 2020 highs of 5.98%

* This reference rate is for conforming Fannie Mae loans, not applicable for overseas borrowers.

Ex-ante

This week, all eyes will be on Jackson Hole, where Fed chair Jerome Powell will speak on the economic outlook at 10 am Washington time. We cannot see Powell becoming incrementally dovish at this stage, while there could be an outside chance of being less hawkish. As a firm, our house view is that given the fact that the “reputation and credibility as an institution” is under pressure, the Fed will risk over-tightening in this economic cycle – right or wrong. To us, tightening into a recession is extremely heavy-handed, but Powell certainly does not want to be remembered as Arthur Burns 2.0. 

The Trillion-dollar question is IF rates will be cut, and if so, how much?

If you look at the Eurodollar implied futures curve, you will see that the market is expecting rates to peak in March 2023 at 3.93% and then start to decline to 3.51% by December 2023, and drop to 3.03% a year later. That is to say; the market is expecting 90 bps of decline in Fed Funds by December 2024! The charts also imply that rates are expected to stay under 3% thereafter.  

3-month Eurodollar Futures Yield Curve

3-Month Eurodollar Futures Yield Curve
Credits: Barchart.com, GMG Macro Research

ISM Manufacturing Index – US 30-Year Mortgage, YoY%, 18-Month Lead Inverse”

One area of potential concern is US industrial production, which is at risk of significant contraction (below 50 on ISM Manufacturing Index is a contraction). If so, this could trigger deeper recession concerns. The next the Institute of Supply Management (ISM) report will be out September 1st. 

If you look at this chart, it appears that the ISM Manufacturing Index (black line) lags the inverse of the US average 30-year mortgage rates (red line) by about 18 months. If the US manufacturing economy pans out in this manner, the Fed may be forced to make deeper cuts and we could see a bigger decline in rates than the market is pricing in, giving another opportunity for US home buyers who are waiting for lower rates! 

Mortgage Rates Graph
Credits: TradingView, GMG Macro Research

Home Prices

There is no impending collapse. We see strength in housing prices.

As we read in the media that home prices are softening, housing starts declining, home prices are falling, and it paints a doom and gloom picture, but we cannot see a collapse in housing prices and a repeat of 2008.  

Did you know that 40% of all homes in the US are held free and clear without a mortgage?

The average outstanding mortgage is 33% of home values. There is simply too much equity in the market for a collapse. Since 2008 underwriting standards have been significantly more stringent with more regulatory oversight. More importantly, most of the outstanding mortgages were printed when rates were below 4%!

Sure, in some cities, there will be softening as residents gentrify out to lower cost of living areas. It’s no surprise that San Francisco, Los Angeles, and New York City are at the tops of those cities where there are significant outflows of residents.  

According to a Redfin article on July 18, 2022, here are the:

Top outflow cities in 2Q2022:

San Francisco48,718Top destination: Sacramento
Los Angeles  40,632Top destination: San Diego
New York City 48,731 Top destination: Philadelphia

Top inflow cities in 2Q2022:

Miami12,614Top origin city: New York City
Tampa7,939Top origin city: Orlando
Phoenix11,464Top origin city: Los Angeles

Buyer’s Guide to California

Over the past 2 weeks, we have published a Deep Dive into what drives overseas buyers to California. In Part 1 – Education. We look at the top 50 public and private high schools in the state, average SAT/ACT scores, Median Income and Average Home prices and conclude the cities with the top schools tend to have the strongest property price appreciation and rental reversions.

In last week’s Part 2 – Demographics. We look at the Asian population in each of these schools and conclude the schools with the highest Asian population is another driver of home prices where the top schools are located.

This week, in Part 3 – Taxes and Benefits. We will conclude the report with a tax guide for overseas investors, how rental income is taxed and various deductions that are allowed.  

Finally, to wrap-up our Buyer’s Guide to California, we will be hosting a webinar with Susan Kim, our Private Client US Concierge Partner and top real estate experts in San Francisco, Palo Alto, Los Angeles, and Orange County to give you an on-the-ground discussion on the respective cities, where the value is now and in the future. Stay tuned!

Loans of the week!

1. Switzerland Family Office purchases luxury condo in New York

Client wanted options outside of their private bank which did not require pledging assets.

Type: Luxury Condo

Price: $20M

Loan Amount: $11M (55% LTV)

Use: Second home

Loan type: America Mortgage HNW+

Qualification: Using borrower’s liquid investment portfolio as a reference without encumbrances. (Example Fidelity account)

Term: 5-year fixed / 30-year amortized

Interest-only: Fixed for 5 years

Rate: 7.875%

2. UK technology entrepreneur purchases home in Atherton (near Palo Alto)

UK-national client attended Stanford and plans to move their children there in 3 years to attend high school. His goal was to rent out the home to tech executives or AirBNB in the interim.

Type: Single-family home

Price: $10.9M

Loan Amount: $6M (55% LTV)

Use: Investment

Loan type: America Mortgage HNW+

Qualification: Using borrower’s liquid investment portfolio as a reference without encumbrances. (Example Fidelity account)

Term: 5-year fixed / 30-year amortized

Interest-only: Fixed for 5 years

Rate: 7.25%

3. Singaporean family purchases home in San Antonio for rental income

Father attended the University of Texas and, after reading our Deep Dive report, decided to own a home where he could take advantage of the strong USD and rental income currently in San Antonio and potentially will move there for retirement.

Type: Single-family home

Price: $350,000

Loan Amount: $245,000 (70% LTV)

Use: Investment

Loan type: America Mortgage Foreign National+

Qualification: Based on overseas income and credit

Term: 30-year fixed

Rate: 6.875%

Thank you and feel free to contact us if you have any questions.

www.americamortgages.com

Buyers Guide to California Pt 2 – Demographics

Buyers Guide to California
Buyers Guide to California Pt 2 - Demographics Matter

CALIFORNIA

Californication, Red Hot Chili Peppers

In last week’s “Buyer’s Guide to California Pt 1 – Education Matters,,” we discussed why Education is an important driver of where overseas borrowers choose to invest in real estate. 

In that report, we looked at the top 50 Public, and Private high schools, average ACT/SAT scores, Median Household Income, Average Home Prices, and Rental Yield.

We argued that when looking at where to make your U.S. property investment, the quality of education in the nearby city/area is a factor in the decision since there is always a notion of “can I live there one day” and “maybe my children can go to school there“. Popular cities in the U.S. will undoubtedly have good schools in the city or in the vicinity. 

“Popularity as a living destination” in turn drives demand, home value appreciation, and strong growth in rental income.

This week we focus on Demographics.

An under-appreciated factor in determining where to own is what city has the most culturally similar population. It’s much easier when you have neighbors that speak your language and share similar cultures and values. 

We will answer these questions (and much more)!

  • Which high schools in California has the highest Asian population?
  • Which cities have the most Korean-born residents?
  • Which cities have the highest total Asian population and the respective top schools?
  • Does the highest Asian population determine how home prices will behave?
  • Which California cities have the highest: Hong Kong, China, Taiwan, India, South Korea, and Philippines-BORN residents?

Demographics matter!

In this study, we solely focus on the Asian population in schools. Asians have been the biggest group of immigrants over the last 60++ years, spurred mainly by the Immigration Act of 1965 but also the Taiwan Relations Act of 1979, the Luce-Celler Act of 1946 as well other obvious political issues of the time.

In addition to the above reasons, many immigrants just wanted a better life for their families, they studied hard, and slowly communities grew around the top education destinations.

Here is the Asian population (>40%) for the top 50 Public and Private Schools in California.

You can also see that these cities have the highest Home Price to Median Income ratios, highlighting the center of attraction for Asians moving to the U.S.

Note a common rule for affordability is for a home price to be UNDER 3x your income!

Public High Schools

Public High Schools - Demographics

Private High Schools

Private High Schools - Demographics

Takeaway – You can see cities where the top schools are located have very high Home Price to Income Ratios which highlights the property value growth driven by families moving to these cities, in particular Asians.

The next study is very interesting!

Our team looks at which California cities have the highest overseas-born residents, specifically from:  China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, South Korea, Philippines, Vietnam, and India.

You guessed it, many are in the cities where the top schools are

Top Cities Taiwan & China Born Population
Top Cities Hong-Kong & Phillippines Born Population
Top Cities India & Korea Born Population
Top Cities VietnamesePopulation

We only used cities with over 20,000 population.

*Refer to full chart below

Here is same chart in Alphabetical Order

Illustrating popular cities ranked by multiple demographics

Popular Cities Ranked by Multiple Demographics

Cities in California For Asians
Average Price to Income Ratio

As you may observe in this report, the cities with the highest Asian immigrant population tend to be where the most demand is, especially when compared to household income, and it’s no surprise it’s also where the top high schools are.

That is to say, the schools and cities mentioned in last week’s report on Education being the main driver of price appreciation and rents are very similar to the cities mentioned in this report.

While this study is not meant to be a rigorous analysis by any means, it is close to my heart since I moved from Singapore to San Francisco when I was 16. My parents had the same thought process…strong Hong Kong population and good schools. I ended up finishing high school in San Francisco and attended UCLA.

Stay tuned for the final part of our Buyer’s Guide to California, where we take a quick look at the general carrying costs for a rental property, including taxes, deductions and other administrative costs. 

Finally, we will be hosting a webinar with our California Partner for a real “on-the-ground” discussion along with a panel of real estate experts for the Bay Area, Palo Alto, Los Angeles, and Orange County. We are still finalising the exact details, but this will be in September. 

Have a good weekend!  If you want a copy of the spreadsheet with the data from our research, please contact us. We are happy to share our findings.

www.americamortgages.com